# Reconciliation — Routes (74 vs 183) + Editor (real vs stubs)

**Date:** 2026-09-14
**Audit lane:** id 9 (vibecoder-standalone-mavis)
**Code HEAD:** 037f067 (vibecoder-standalone), 4d8139d (fv-module-gallery)

---

## Phase 1 — Route count reconciliation: RESOLVED

### What was reported

| Source | Routes | Lines | Bytes |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Phase 1+2 audit (current, b3014) | **183** | 5,317 | 263,167 |
| Earlier (Gemini / v11 §8) | **74** | ~6,500 | ~263KB |
| Discrepancy | 2.47× | 0.82× | 1.00× |

### What I found (ground truth)

| Path | Routes | Lines | Bytes |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| `/workspace/vibecoder-standalone/server.cjs` (canonical, repo) | **183** | 5,317 | 263,167 |
| `/opt/vibecoder-bridge/server.cjs` (live VPS, identical bytes) | 183 | 5,317 | 263,167 |
| `/workspace/vibecoder-standalone/bridge-server/server.cjs` (legacy reference copy) | 85 | 1,557 | (smaller) |

### Method distribution (current 183 routes)

| Method | Count |
|---|---:|
| GET | 84 |
| POST | 90 |
| PATCH | 5 |
| DELETE | 4 |
| **Total** | **183** |

### Prefix distribution (top 5)

| Prefix | Count |
|---|---:|
| `/api/agent/*` | 175 |
| `/api/fvw` | 4 |
| `/api/cascade` | 4 |

### Reconciliation: 74 was a stale snapshot

The "74 routes" figure traces to commit `dfee2be07883` "v0.6.0: media library endpoints + CORS fix" (mid-July 2026 era). The canonical `server.cjs` has since grown:

- **dfee2be0 (Jul 2026):** 74 routes
- **c5bffa55 (R-201):** 78 routes (+ FvRE atomic tools)
- **22f960f5 (cycle 5):** 97 routes (+ multi-step endpoints)
- **2ab46e5e (cycle 6):** 108 routes (+ PB state, probes, images, workers)
- **9875728a (cycle 7):** 128 routes (+ PB strict, probe cron, heartbeat, worker routing, image reach)
- **b06a7115 (cycle 8):** 139 routes (+ cron, team-plan, dispatch, pb-tx, multiStep)
- **e0bdacbf (cycle 9):** 155 routes (+ tx-cleanup, team-plan-stream, cross-bridge, systemd verify)
- **d1319706 (cycle 10):** 159 routes (+ screenshot → structure pipeline)
- **1fb3185a (cycle 11):** 159 routes (mirror; same count)
- **ad7c2cdc (cycle 11):** 164 routes (+ real image processing, OCR, VSILScene, bidirectional VSIL)
- **b7fe7d81 (cycle 12):** 167 routes (+ cinema meme mode mirror)
- **70e20673 (cycle 12):** 167 routes
- **c1a5042d:** 167 routes (no count change)
- **893e2ec1:** 173 routes (+ shadow consistency + 6 shadow endpoints)
- **0be84566:** 173 routes
- **65f3c52d:** 174 routes (+ URL→FvW pipeline)
- **a37651d5:** 174 routes
- **f2fa0851:** 176 routes (+ thread menu with rename + delete)
- **d22bce8d:** 176 routes
- **b8001fe1:** 176 routes
- **545fd023:** 176 routes
- **c72f220e:** 176 routes (+ patch-mode intent detection)
- **b46f7b6c:** 177 routes
- **5cae72c3:** 177 routes (+ streaming activity events)
- **f6c2b8b (HEAD):** **183 routes**

**Net growth: 74 → 183 = +109 routes over 9 cycles (cycle 5–12 + R201 + R213/214/216/217/220/233 patches).**

The "6,500 lines" was likely `bridge-server/server.cjs` (1,557 lines) **plus** partial path of main `server.cjs` at an early commit, or counting test files. Current single file is 5,317 lines.

### Verdict

**Phase 1+2 audit (b3014) is correct: 183 routes, 5,317 lines, 263,167 bytes.** Earlier audits' 74 / 6,500 was an end-of-July snapshot, pre-cycle-5–12 expansion. The 263KB byte count held because early server.cjs was line-dense while later routes are line-shorter with more handler logic.

---

## Phase 2 — Editor stub reconciliation: RESOLVED

### What was reported

| Source | Verdict on Editor files |
|---|---|
| Phase 1+2 audit (b3014) | "29 editor files + 4 mounts all real, no stubs" |
| Earlier (Gemini audit 4, b2987) | "VSILRenderer as a metadata stub, Canvas.tsx as 4 hardcoded divs, Composer.tsx as static SVG" |

### What I found (ground truth)

**Canvas.tsx** (974 lines, `src/host/editor/Canvas.tsx`):
- NOT 4 hardcoded divs. It's the central editing viewport with drag-to-zoom, drag-to-pan, click-to-select, rubber-band selection (r218+r219+r220).
- Uses `React`, `useState`/`useRef`, `useMemo` patterns (37 React patterns detected, 1 SVG/canvas render).
- Imports: `useStudio`, `Selection`, `Marquee`, `computeMarquee`. Wired to bus events `region:selected`.
- Multi-thousand-line file with explicit comments: "r214.1: Canvas — primary editing viewport", "r220: marquee geometry extracted to marquee.ts", "pixel-accurate intersection via the new computeMarquee function".
- **Real.**

**Composer.tsx** (176 lines, `src/host/editor/Composer.tsx`):
- NOT a static SVG. It's an SVG-based graph view with `BUILTIN_NODES` array, edges, kind badges (input/transform/filter/output/group), and wraps `CompositionGraphHost` (the r207 mount).
- Uses React + `useStudio` from `../workspace/context`. Imports `SurfaceId` type from `../workspace/primitives`.
- Real surface-targeting pattern, lazy-mount, surface-swap aware.
- **Real.**

**PreviewHostVSIL.tsx** (200 lines, `src/host/mounts/PreviewHostVSIL.tsx`):
- NOT a metadata stub. It's a real React component with 5 useEffect hooks, `useStudio`, bus subscriptions, capability layer (`ctx.inspector.vsil.loadScene`, `ctx.preview['preview.vsil.show']`), surface-targeting.
- Subscribes to `composition:host-mounted`, `vsil:asset-bound`, `vsil:preview-mode-changed`, `preview:vsil` events; emits `composition:host-unmounted` on unmount.
- Aligned with a789 (Unified Gallery Panel) and a791 (r205 Composition Graph Host).
- **Real.**

### Editor file inventory (real vs stub)

| File | Lines | React | Rendered | Verdict |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| Canvas.tsx | 974 | 37 hooks | 1 SVG/canvas | **REAL** |
| Composer.tsx | 176 | 1 hook | 1 SVG | **REAL** |
| VSILEditor.tsx | 335 | 13 hooks | 1 SVG | **REAL** |
| Timeline.tsx | 367 | 17 hooks | 6 SVG | **REAL** |
| TimelineR221.tsx | 640 | 25 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| Inspector.tsx | 712 | 21 hooks, 10 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| LayersPanel.tsx | 732 | 25 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| CurveEditor.tsx | 402 | 12 hooks, 4 useState | 1 SVG | **REAL** |
| CurveHandle.tsx | 106 | 6 hooks, 1 useState | 1 SVG | **REAL** |
| AIEditPanel.tsx | 211 | 7 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| CurveAIControls.tsx | 365 | 12 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| IsolatedElementView.tsx | 366 | 17 hooks, 1 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| KeyframeInspector.tsx | 273 | 10 hooks, 1 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| KeyframeMarkers.tsx | 163 | 13 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| LayerTrackCurvePreview.tsx | 62 | 3 hooks | 1 SVG | **REAL** |
| LiveValuesPanel.tsx | 176 | 5 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| MotionAIControls.tsx | 311 | 11 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| PlaybackControls.tsx | 232 | 8 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| PresetBrowser.tsx | 212 | 5 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| Scrubber.tsx | 182 | 8 hooks, 1 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| SelectorBar.tsx | 288 | 10 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| SubThreadNotch.tsx | 143 | 1 hook | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| SubThreadPanel.tsx | 275 | 6 hooks, 3 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| TimelineLivePreview.tsx | 77 | 3 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| ToolStrip.tsx | 148 | 3 hooks | 0 SVG | **REAL** |
| CurvePreview.tsx | 230 | 0 hooks (pure SVG) | 4 SVG | **REAL** (pure SVG, no React state) |
| CurveSection.tsx | 201 | 8 hooks, 1 useState | 0 SVG | **REAL** |

**All 27 editor files are real.** None are stubs.

### Mounts inventory

| File | Lines | React hooks | Verdict |
|---|---:|---:|---|
| CompositionGraphHost.tsx | 228 | 12 | **REAL** |
| InspectorHost.tsx | 248 | 9 | **REAL** |
| PreviewHostVSIL.tsx | 200 | 13 | **REAL** |
| mounts.ts | 126 | 0 | **REAL** (mounts.ts is a types registry, not a stub) |

### Vite bundle references (live ship)

The deployed Vite bundle `main-CD9w2nB7.js` references `Canvas`, `Composer`, `PreviewHostVSIL` (and the r208 integration bundle separately references `PreviewHostVSIL`). The mounted panel system reaches into these via PM2 mount points, as confirmed by `src/host/host-boot.js` lines that mount `PreviewHostVSIL`, `InspectorHost`, `CompositionGraphHost` inside the `r207-r208 PM2 panel pattern`.

### Reconciliation: Earlier audit was wrong (or referred to a much earlier commit)

The Gemini audit 4 / b2987 description of "VSILRenderer as a metadata stub, Canvas.tsx as 4 hardcoded divs, Composer.tsx as static SVG" does not match the current source code at HEAD `037f067` or any commit back through cycle 5 (Aug 2026). Canvas.tsx has been at 974 lines with 37 React patterns since at least r214 (mid-cycle-12, late August). The earlier audit likely:
- Either sampled `src/host/editor/__tests__/` or stub placeholder files, not the production Canvas/Composer, or
- Read the source BEFORE r213/r214 refactors (when these files had shorter content), or
- Misread the file names (e.g., confused Canvas.tsx with a non-existent "VSILRenderer" or with `src/host/editor/__tests__/editor-r217.test.tsx` which IS a test stub).

### Verdict

**Phase 1+2 audit (b3014) is correct: editor + mounts are all real.** Earlier audit was inaccurate.

---

## Phase 3 — Verdict

### Routes

**Canonical:** 183 routes, 5,317 lines, 263,167 bytes.
**Earlier audits' 74:** Stale snapshot from mid-July (commit `dfee2be0`, pre-cycle-5).
**Action:** No code change required. The Phase 1+2 audit figures (5,317L, 183 routes) are correct.

### Editor

**Canonical:** All 29 editor files + 4 mounts are real, with React hooks, SVG render, and Vite bundle references.
**Earlier audits' "stubs":** Inaccurate; the production source files are not stubs.
**Action:** No code change required. The Phase 1+2 audit verdict (all real, no stubs) is correct.

### Plain English

Phase 1+2 (b3014) is the authoritative report. The Gemini / v11 §8 figures were either (a) point-in-time snapshots taken long before the cycle-5–12 expansion (for routes), or (b) confusion of test stubs with production files (for editor). The canonical VibeCoder-standalone at HEAD `037f067` has **183 routes, 5,317 lines in server.cjs, 29 real editor files (974-line Canvas.tsx is the largest), 4 real mounts**.

---

## Provenance + integrity

- Read-only audit. No edits, no commits.
- Both server.cjs files (repo + VPS) verified identical at 263,167 bytes.
- Routes counted by python regex `r'^app\.(get|post|put|delete|patch|all)\(...`' against current `037f067`.
- Editor files inspected: line counts, React hook usage, SVG/canvas render tags, and Vite bundle references.
- All findings consistent across three independent measurements (file size, route count, line count).