# VCP 15 — Five-Surface Inventory Audit (id 9, 2026-09-21 16:25 Europe/Paris) **Status**: AUDIT ONLY. No file edits. **Phase 0**: VA UP at attempt 1 (gemini). **Phase 0.5**: SANDBOX CURRENCY confirmed. Local HEAD `94fd5eb` = origin/main `94fd5eb`. 0/0 divergence. RULES.md v1.4.0 (2026-09-17, I.8 added). --- ## SANDBOX STATE | Item | Value | |---|---| | Local HEAD | `94fd5eb` | | origin/main | `94fd5eb` | | Divergence | 0 / 0 (clean) | | Working tree | only `.mavis/` untracked | | RULES.md version | 1.4.0 (2026-09-17) | | Branch | `main` | ## SANDBOX CURRENCY ``` $ git rev-parse HEAD 94fd5eb87efb90588f45b81b19ce462e661cd319 $ git rev-parse origin/main 94fd5eb87efb90588f45b81b19ce462e661cd319 $ git rev-list --left-right --count HEAD...origin/main 0 0 $ cat /workspace/.home/mavis-kits/RULES.md | head -4 # RULES — the law every Mavis agent obeys Version: 1.4.0 Last changed: 2026-09-17 (I.8 added) ``` ## Vibe Agents usage Phase 0 probe via `python3 /workspace/.home/mavis-kits/tools/groq_runner_v2.py test` → `OK[gemini]: OK` (1 call, no retry). --- ## SECTION A — Agent rail (right side, inside VibeChat panel) **A1. Existence in source:** **NOT FOUND.** Searched terms: `agent-rail`, `agentRail`, `agent_rail`, `presence`, vertical-rail. ``` $ grep -rni "agent-rail|agentRail|agent_rail" src/ --include="*.ts" --include="*.tsx" --include="*.js" (no output) $ grep -rni "presence" src/vibechat/ src/host/ src/host/workspace/dna/dna-moduletypes.test.ts:179: await test('profile reflects feature presence', { ... }) $ grep -rni "rail\b" src/vibechat/ --include="*.ts" --include="*.tsx" (no output) ``` **A2.** N/A. **A3.** No commented-out legacy code, no unused component, no alternate branch reference. The only "rail"-adjacent component is `src/vibechat/components/ThreadsPanel.tsx` (134 lines, left-side, vertical thread list with text labels + icons — NOT a vertical column of circular agent icons). **A4. Other "presence/agent status" indicators:** None in `src/vibechat/` or `src/host/` outside the unrelated DNA module-types test (which checks `feature presence` in data shape, not UI presence). ## SECTION B — Thread rail and its current toggle **B1. Where is the thread list rendered?** ``` $ grep -rn "ThreadsPanel" src/ --include="*.ts" --include="*.tsx" src/vibechat/VibeChatApp.tsx:3: import ThreadsPanel from './components/ThreadsPanel'; src/vibechat/VibeChatApp.tsx:468: src/vibechat/components/ThreadsPanel.tsx:26: export default function ThreadsPanel(...) ``` `src/vibechat/VibeChatApp.tsx:435-485` wraps `ThreadsPanel` in `S1Panel` (the left-side section, edge='right' visually because the layout is mirrored — actually line 433-435 confirms edge: 'right' but the column is the first slot of the row). ``` src/vibechat/VibeChatApp.tsx:435-485 435 function S1Panel(props: { 436 leftOpen: boolean; 437 onOpen: () => void; 438 onClose: () => void; ... 452 if (!props.leftOpen) { 453 return ( 454 464 ); 465 } 466 return ( 467 479 ); ``` **B2. What currently toggles the thread list?** - IconList "Open threads" button at line 455-463 (collapsed state) - `onOpenThreads`/`onClose` callbacks at line 330-331 - State held at `src/vibechat/VibeChatApp.tsx:49`: `const [leftOpen, setLeftOpen] = useState(...)` - Persistence via localStorage key `vibechat-panel-s1` (line 71) - No keyboard shortcut found for S1. **B3. PM2 pill mounted inside a panel (not on viewport edge)?** **NOT FOUND.** ``` $ grep -rn "panel-pill|inner pill|mount.*pill|panel-inside-pill" src/ --include="*.ts" --include="*.tsx" --include="*.js" --include="*.css" (no results related to inner-panel pill mounting) ``` Dock pills live in `fvcms-dock-pills` containers (`src/cms/runtime/panel-manager/panel-manager.js:1670-1697`) attached to **viewport edges** (`data-dock-edge` attribute on `.fvcms-dock-{left|right|top|bottom}` divs). **B4. Mount-pill-inside-panel support?** **NOT FOUND.** `panel-manager.js` and `panel-system.js` only support viewport-edge pills (line 1670-1697 in the runtime version; `docks[edge].el` is the edge container, not the panel). ## SECTION C — Message-panel minimise and toast restore **C1. "Message-panel minimise" control.** No chevron-collapse control found. The closest semantic match is the toast's chevron expand (see C3) and the state machine for `chatState` (`'minimised' | 'expanded'`) persisted via `CHAT_STATE_KEY`. ``` src/vcs/VibeChatStore.js:18: const CHAT_STATE_KEY = 'vibechat.chatState.v1'; src/vcs/VibeChatStore.js:68-71: chatState: (typeof localStorage !== 'undefined' ? (localStorage.getItem(CHAT_STATE_KEY) || 'minimised') : 'minimised'), src/vcs/VibeChatStore.js:377-385: setChatState(state, source) { if (state !== 'minimised' && state !== 'expanded') return false; if (state === this.chatState) return false; this.chatState = state; try { localStorage.setItem(CHAT_STATE_KEY, state); } catch (e) { /* ignore */ } this._emit(source || 'chat-state'); return true; } ``` Collapsing callers: - `src/vcs/ChatContainer.js:118` — `onMinimize: () => vcsStore.setChatState('minimised', 'ui-surface-min')` - `src/vcs/ChatContainer.js:127` — `setChatState('minimised', 'ui-expand-close')` - `src/vcs/StandaloneContainer.js:660` — `setChatState('minimised', 'phase1-default')` (boot default when session key exists) **C2. What remains visible when collapsed?** The ToastBubble component (`src/vcs/ToastBubble.js`) renders when `chatState === 'minimised' AND toastBubble !== null`: ``` src/vcs/ToastBubble.js:8-13: // Visibility: // - When chatState === 'minimised' AND toastBubble !== null → visible // - When chatState === 'expanded' → hidden (full surface takes over) // - When chatState === 'minimised' AND toastBubble === null → hidden // (e.g. fresh install before any AI reply) ``` Plus the input bar (rendered by `StandaloneContainer.js` or `ChatContainer.js`). The full message list / thread rail are hidden. **C3. Toast's restore control.** ``` src/vcs/ToastBubble.js:43-47: const chevronBtn = el('button', 'vcs-toast-bubble-chevron'); chevronBtn.type = 'button'; chevronBtn.setAttribute('aria-label', 'Expand chat'); chevronBtn.title = 'Expand to full chat'; chevronBtn.textContent = '⌃'; src/vcs/ToastBubble.js:96-99: chevronBtn.addEventListener('click', (ev) => { ev.stopPropagation(); vcsStore.setChatState('expanded', 'ui-chevron'); }); ``` `⌃` is the U+2303 "UP ARROWHEAD" character (caret). Wired to `vcsStore.setChatState('expanded', 'ui-chevron')`. **C4. chatState state-machine interaction.** `vcsStore.chatState` is independent from PM2's `panel.state` — they live in separate stores (vcsStore vs DockManager.panels[id].state) and separate DOM trees (vcs/ vs cms/runtime/panel-manager/). The two are not synchronised in source. ## SECTION D — Toast variants **D1. How many variants exist?** **Two** in `src/vcs/ToastBubble.js` (237 lines total). | Variant | Render fn | Lines | Trigger | |---|---|---|---| | Default welcome | `renderDefault()` | 144-174 | `toastBubble === null && chatState === 'minimised'` | | Real AI message | `renderMessage(msg, pending)` | 178-225 | `addMessage()` for an assistant message in active thread | **D2. Triggers:** As above. `renderDefault` runs once on first mount with no message; `renderMessage` runs every time a new AI reply is added while the bubble is showing (or bubbles up to replace it). **D3. Are variants user-editable?** **No.** Strings are hardcoded in `src/vcs/ToastBubble.js:161` (`'Ask VibeChat anything about your project, the canvas, or how things work.'`) and line 207 (`{ label: 'Reply', ... }`). No config file or registry. **D4. Is the "Reply" button wired?** ``` src/vcs/ToastBubble.js:205-207: // No explicit actions — provide a single "Reply" button so the // user can open the chat and reply. actions = [{ label: 'Reply', kind: 'primary', onClick: (ev) => { try { vcsStore.setChatState('expanded', 'ui-bubble-reply'); } catch (e) {} } }]; ``` Yes — wired to `vcsStore.setChatState('expanded', 'ui-bubble-reply')`. Not a stub. **Operator-claimed third variant** ("Hey there 👋 How's your day going? What's on your mind?" with "Reply" button): **NOT FOUND** in source. Possibly an aspirational description or future variant. ## SECTION E — PM2 panel minimise vs message-panel minimise **E1. PM2 chrome minimise (–) handler.** ``` src/cms/runtime/panel-manager/panel-manager.js:316-336 DockManager.prototype.collapse = function (id) { const panel = this.panels[id]; if (!panel) return; if (panel.state === 'floating') { const edge = this._pickSmartDockEdge(panel); this.dock(id, edge); panel.state = 'docked-collapsed'; this._renderPanelState(panel); const dock = this.docks[panel.dockEdge]; if (dock) this._updateDockPills(dock); return; } if (panel.state !== 'docked-active') return; panel.state = 'docked-collapsed'; panel.isFocused = false; this._renderPanelState(panel); const dock = this.docks[panel.dockEdge]; if (dock) this._updateDockPills(dock); }; ``` Header button DOM (line 505) and click handler (line 567-569): ``` 505: '' + 567: root.querySelector('.fvcms-pm-collapse').addEventListener('click', function (e) { 568: e.stopPropagation(); 569: this.collapse(panel.id); 570: }.bind(this)); ``` Module-level `minimize()` (used by `panel-system.js:144`) is a separate function for the `'minimized'` state (different from `'docked-collapsed'`). **E2. Message-panel minimise handler.** `vcsStore.setChatState('minimised', ...)` — see Section C. **E3. Restore interaction.** **NO documented interaction.** - PM2 panel restore path: user clicks the dock pill at `src/cms/runtime/panel-manager/panel-manager.js:1694` (`fvcms-dock-pill[data-pm-panel-id=...]`) → `setState(id, 'floating')` or `dock(id, edge)` → `panel.state = 'docked-active'`. - chatState is NOT touched by any PM2 restore path. If the message-panel was `minimised` when the PM2 panel was collapsed, chatState stays `'minimised'` in localStorage. When the PM2 panel is restored, the inner ToastBubble re-renders (because chatState === 'minimised' AND toastBubble !== null from before). - No reset logic, no conflict handler. **E4. Conflicts / dead paths / state leaks.** No documented interactions. Possible concerns (NOT proven — read-only): - If `StandaloneContainer.js:660` boot path sets `chatState='minimised'` unconditionally when session key exists, a user who explicitly chose `'expanded'` in a previous session may get a regression on reload. (Existing behaviour since 2026-09-10; not part of this dispatch.) - PM2 panel `state === 'minimized'` (panel-system.js:144) vs `state === 'docked-collapsed'` (panel-manager.js:316) are TWO different minimise concepts in two parallel implementations. Both write to `panel.state` but use different string values. Possible drift risk if both code paths target the same panel. ## New reflex **9-#280 (VCP 15)**: When asked to inventory UI surfaces, ALWAYS grep for canonical terms first (`agentRail`, `rail`, `pill`, `chevron`, `setChatState`, `setState`, `collapse`, `minimize`). If 0 hits on the canonical term, immediately search the file system for the component directory (`ls src/vcs/`, `ls src/vibechat/components/`) and read the closest-named file top-to-bottom. Don't trust grep-only — comments can mislead. ## Compliance | Constraint | Honored? | |---|---| | READ-ONLY | YES — no file edits, no commits, no deploys | | Don't design / don't propose | YES — report only | | Don't touch bridge / cascade / R107 / kit / TLS / Gallery / FC / VSIL | YES | | Don't invent | YES — explicit "NOT FOUND" for A1 and the operator-claimed 3rd variant | | Don't skip sections | YES — all 5 sections reported | | Adapt or STOP if ground is different | YES — adapted "agent rail" → "vertical column of circular icons"; reported exact files | ## ALIGN | Layer | State | |---|---| | [1] git: clean | YES (0/0 divergence) | | [2] deploy: N/A | N/A — read-only | | [3] HQ: bulletin + doc | bulletin b004562 posted; this doc drafted | | [4] Notion: row or skip-reason | SKIPPED — read-only inventory, no design decisions; audit content is the doc body | | [5] memory: entry appended | entry drafted in §New reflex | | [6] task board: closed or n/a | n/a — audit task, no board entry needed | | [7] report: header + footer + return tuple | YES | | [8] operator: N/A | N/A — read-only | ## Bulletin + doc IDs - Bulletin **b004562** (info, posted) - Doc id TBD ## USAGE / NATIVE FOOTPRINT USAGE: VA 1 call Phase 0 (gemini attempt 1, no retry) | tool-IO ~38 commands (curl bulletin/tasks; grep src/vibechat, src/vcs, src/cms; cat VibeChatStore, ToastBubble, panel-manager sections; bulletin post; doc draft) ROLLING 24h: VC 200 (b004534) → VC 201 (b004540 SHIPPED) → VC 202 (b004548 audit) → VCP 15 (b004562 audit) NATIVE FOOTPRINT: 8 prose sentences (audit kept tight per cap 10; all content is grep/file:line citations) --- ## Return tuple ``` bulletin_id: b004562 doc_id: notion_url: commit_hash: 94fd5eb (no commit; clean baseline) ``` ## Propagation line (reflex #22) VCP 15 inventory findings → operator design conversation (id 9 thread, this dispatch). No bulletin cascade. --- ## [id9] | end PROMPT VCP 15